California has some of the most developed health privacy law in the country, and much of it is more stringent than HIPAA. The Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (CMIA) predates HIPAA and reaches some organizations HIPAA does not. The California Consumer Privacy Act, as amended by the CPRA, exempts PHI governed by HIPAA but not every other kind of data a healthcare organization holds. And licensed health facilities face their own reporting duties for unauthorized access.
We help providers, plans, business associates and health technology companies serving Californians build HIPAA programs that also account for these state requirements, with legal interpretation handled by their counsel.
Key points
- The CMIA can apply to entities that are not HIPAA covered entities, including some software and app providers.
- CCPA/CPRA exempts HIPAA PHI, but website data, employee data and non-PHI consumer data can still be in scope.
- Licensed health facilities have state reporting duties for unauthorized access that run alongside HIPAA breach rules.
- Where California law is more protective of medical privacy, it is not preempted by HIPAA.
How we serve California clients
California engagements run remotely, with on-site visits arranged where a physical walkthrough or in-person workshop is worthwhile. The California-specific work centers on data mapping — sorting what is PHI, what is CMIA "medical information", and what is ordinary personal information — because that sorting decides which rules apply.
The CMIA: California’s medical confidentiality law
The Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (California Civil Code §56 and following) restricts disclosure of medical information by providers, health plans and their contractors, and generally requires patient authorization for disclosures that fall outside its listed exceptions. It also reaches certain businesses that offer software or hardware designed to maintain medical information so that individuals can manage it — which can bring some consumer health apps into scope even where HIPAA does not apply. Recent amendments have extended CMIA coverage to additional categories such as certain mental health and reproductive or sexual health digital services; verify the current scope with counsel.
Two features make the CMIA particularly significant. Its authorization requirements are in some respects stricter than HIPAA’s, and it provides individuals with a private right of action. HIPAA has no private right of action.
| Topic | HIPAA | CMIA |
|---|---|---|
| Who is covered | Covered entities and business associates | Providers, plans, contractors and certain software/app businesses |
| Authorization form | Elements in 45 CFR §164.508 | California-specific content and formatting requirements |
| Private lawsuits | No private right of action | Private right of action available |
| Preemption | Federal floor | Not preempted where more stringent |
CCPA/CPRA and the PHI exemption
The CCPA, as amended by the CPRA, exempts PHI collected by a covered entity or business associate governed by HIPAA, and medical information governed by the CMIA. It also treats a covered entity’s handling of patient information like PHI in certain respects. But the exemption is information-based, not entity-based. A hospital or health tech company can still be a "business" under the CCPA for data that is not PHI.
- Website and marketing analytics data, including tracking pixels, that is not PHI may fall under the CCPA. OCR has also issued guidance on online tracking technologies under HIPAA; its status has been affected by litigation, so verify the current position.
- Employee and job applicant data is generally not PHI and may be in CCPA scope.
- B2B contact data and consumer data collected outside a treatment relationship may be in scope.
- De-identified patient information carries specific CCPA requirements, including contract terms and notice language for sale or license; confirm details with counsel.
Turning California law into controls
- 1
Classify your data
Separate PHI, CMIA medical information, CCPA personal information and de-identified data. This classification drives everything else.
- 2
Review authorization and consent forms
Confirm forms meet both HIPAA §164.508 and CMIA requirements; this is legal review territory, so involve counsel.
- 3
Audit online tracking
Inventory pixels, SDKs and analytics on patient-facing sites and apps, and decide which rules apply to each data flow.
- 4
Strengthen access monitoring
Unauthorized access is a reportable event in California facilities. Audit logs under §164.312(b) need someone actually reviewing them.
- 5
Update incident response
Add California regulator and patient notice paths, with timelines, to the plan our breach response consulting helps build.
Where California work usually starts
For most California clients, the most useful first step is a HIPAA gap analysis with a California overlay, followed by Privacy Rule consulting on authorizations and disclosures. Health tech companies often start by determining whether they are a business associate, a CMIA-covered software provider, or both. City-specific considerations for Los Angeles-area organizations are covered on our Los Angeles page.
Frequently asked questions
Does HIPAA preempt the CMIA?
Generally no, where the CMIA is more protective of medical privacy. Under 45 CFR §160.203, more stringent state privacy provisions are not preempted, so many organizations must comply with both.
Are we exempt from the CCPA because we are a HIPAA covered entity?
Not entirely. The exemption covers PHI and CMIA medical information, not all data. Website analytics, employee data and other non-PHI personal information may still be in scope if you meet the CCPA’s business thresholds.
Can the CMIA apply to a health app that is not covered by HIPAA?
It can. The CMIA reaches certain businesses offering software or hardware designed to maintain medical information, and its scope has been expanded by amendments. Confirm with counsel whether your product is covered.
How fast must a California hospital report unauthorized access?
California sets a short deadline measured in business days for reporting to the Department of Public Health and affected patients — much faster than HIPAA’s outer limit. Confirm the current statutory timeline and exceptions with counsel.
Authoritative sources
- HHS — Preemption of state law (HIPAA FAQs)
- California Attorney General — Privacy
- HHS — HIPAA Privacy Rule
- eCFR — 45 CFR Part 164 (Security, Privacy and Breach Notification Rules)
This page is general information, not legal advice. Regulations and guidance change; confirm current requirements with the official sources above and, where needed, qualified legal counsel.